I crate trained Rose and it worked out beautifully. For me, it wasn't all about potty training, it was also about keeping her safe when I wasn't home. I would of feared for her throughout the day....what is she getting into? Has she ripped up that magazine on the table into a zillion little pieces? I wanted to set Rose up for success. Once Rose proved that she could be left out of the crate while not at home, I eased into it. Starting slowly, maybe I'd leave her out while I ran to the store, then maybe while at dinner, then a few hours....once again, not overwhelming her and setting her up for success. At this point, I only use the crate for long distance traveling. I do still have it set up, and sometimes when I come home I find her snuggled up in her crate. She loves her crate, it's her safe place.